The first innovation introduced by regulation 2017/2455 concerns the concept of territoriality established by directive 2006/112/EC, which can be defined as a sort of general single text applied at the Community level to regulate VAT taxation.
The single text came into effect on January 1, 2007, and in the case of distance sales to private individuals, it provided the basic principle of applying a tax based on the country of the service provider. This means that VAT was applied with reference to the location where an e-commerce was registered, and therefore, given its virtual reality, the registration of the VAT number or the residence of the company was considered.
This type of system appeared quite simple in managing payments in retail sales to individuals, but it had the consequence of creating a certain imbalance from a market perspective, thus favoring those sites located in countries with a more favorable VAT regime and therefore more advantageous product taxation.
The new European regulation still maintains the idea of territoriality, but with reference to the country of the private individual making the purchase and not the one where the e-commerce is located. In particular, Article 33 of regulation 2017/2455 emphasizes the parameters to be evaluated, specifying that the taxation of VAT must refer to the place where the item was delivered and not the one from which the shipment originated.
So, for example, if one has an e-commerce registered in Italy and a purchase is made in Spain, the value-added tax, or VAT applied, will be that of the latter nation.
However, the aspect related to territoriality brings a series of problems for e-commerce. In fact, in the case of orders coming from different countries, one would have to pay VAT in all the individual countries where the orders will be delivered: a reality that implies certain logistical difficulties and also significant costs.